Posted by: Kara Luker | November 28, 2023

I’m keeping these because…?

(Audio version available above)

After John wondered aloud last night about whether a bomb had exploded in our closet, I decided to finish unpacking from our Thanksgiving trip to Sacramento and sort through a collection of various items scattered on the floor. As I was putting away my UGG boots, my eyes landed on an old pair of walking shoes sitting atop my shoe rack. They were retired at least a year ago, far later than they should have been, and yet there they proudly sat as if they still possessed some level of usefulness. 

The shoes look pretty rough from the top, but the real story is told when you flip them over. The tread is almost completely gone, leaving a slick surface incapable of providing a secure footing. The heels have collapsed or disintegrated (or both), allowing any rough surface to be keenly felt through the soft layer that remains, not to mention the sticks and pebbles that get easily lodged in the holes that go all the way through the sole. And yet I kept wearing these shoes despite months of John’s hearty encouragement to replace them. Not only that, but once I finally did, I somehow deemed them worthy of keeping.

I can think of a few reasons for these odd choices. The first is the comfort of familiarity. The shoes were worn in and had clearly worked for me – to some degree – for a long while. The second is having an outdated mindset that isn’t based in my current reality. While I now have the resources to replace things that are broken down or are not serving me well, that wasn’t always the case. The third (and the primary reason for keeping the old shoes) is the perceived need for a backup in case the new ones fail.

This whole ridiculous thing got me thinking about some old habits and mindsets that are proudly sitting in the closet of my heart, as if they still possess some shred of usefulness. The one that caught my eye was the well worn coping mechanism of self-reliance. I realize that our culture places a high value on this and it may look wearable from the top, but if you flip it over, you will see the absence of tread to provide a sure footing on the slippery surfaces of this world, collapsed surfaces that can’t protect the tender parts of our lives from the rough things we will walk through and deep holes that let sharp irritants through without resistance. 

Self-reliance most certainly bears the comfort of familiarity to me and I guess you could say it “worked” to some degree for a long time, but it ultimately brought me nothing but striving, perfectionism, performance and addiction. It makes sense that I finally followed the encouragement to replace it with something new, namely dependence on a very loving God and a beautiful, growing interdependence with my community. Since then, I have found myself protected from the dangers of the roads I tread, walking in safety and in the peace that comes from trusting my “equipment.” Best decision ever! And yet, despite the vast resources now at my disposal, I still sometimes get stuck in the old mindset of my own meager, self-sufficient resources. This creates fear and the perceived need for a backup to the new way. Hence the coping mechanism sitting on the shelf… just in case. And because it’s there and I know it so well, I sometimes put it back on and feel fortified, as if this broken-down thing could give me what I need for any circumstance that comes my way.

I am seeing the absolute absurdity of holding onto this mechanism, the old mindset that produced it and the fear that drives it. It just doesn’t make sense in light of what I know now; of what I have experienced of love and provision and abundance. So I’m thinking that, by the grace of God, I am going to throw it in the trash bin next to yesterday’s scraps and yesteryear’s shoes to head to the landfill where it belongs. Is there something sitting on the shelf of your heart that might be worth throwing away too?

Do not conform to the pattern of this world, but be transformed by the renewing of your mind. Romans 12:2


Responses

  1. Patty hesaidwhatks's avatar

    This really spoke to me, Kara. I love the practical application you used to drive home this powerful spiritual principle. I am reminded of the fact that I am a new creature in Christ, and the old doesn’t mix at all with the new. Why do I open my closet of old worn-out clothes when God has given me a beautiful new wardrobe. Thank you so much for writing this in a way that I will remember.

    • Kara Luker's avatar

      Thank you Patty! I love the way you articulated that. Makes me think of the verse of being clothed in garments of salvation and wrapped in robes of righteousness. A far better wardrobe! ❤️

  2. Just Bob F's avatar

    Oh yeah, the “I don’t need anybody” gene runs strong in me. Maybe it’s because the people I depended on when I was a child failed to be reliable in the important things. I was well fed and clothed, but the various feuds and leavings left me determined never to depend on anyone for anything. It took me a long time to realize that I had no chance or ability to do that, and that my gracious God was going to do for me whether I wanted Him to or not. After eight decades of life, I’m finally getting a clue. Good that you’ve learned at an early age. Thanks for this reminder.

    • Kara Luker's avatar

      It’s always good to know I’m not alone! And certainly good to see God’s goodness, no matter how slow or stubborn we may be in getting there 😊

  3. Kim Coenen's avatar

    Wonderful metaphor Kara!
    I know one of my tried and not so helpful habits is self-reliance, also. Not helpful especially when I’m way out of my depths with not a clue how to get back to shore. It can be quite lonely out there. Thankfully God uses the loneliness to motivate me to ask for help. 😉

    • Kara Luker's avatar

      It really isn’t helpful at all, is it?! But I’m so grateful for the motivators that help us to want connection and help and a better way. So much love to you 💕

  4. seekingdivineperspective's avatar

    I had a similar epiphany when I had a rose garden. I spent the earlier part of the summer fretting and obsessing over bringing back the roses that had gone through a rough winter and were 99% dead. The time I spent babying them could have been so much better spent on other endeavors. It felt good to finally pull them up and replace them with healthy new bushes.

    • Kara Luker's avatar

      It is always such a good moment to see things clearly and be able to move on! I hope your new ones are healthy and happy 😊


Leave a reply to rwfrohlich Cancel reply

Categories