Knowing that she will get a treat if she stops barking, Sunny, our family dog, often now regulates herself without the once-necessary command and then races to find me for her reward. There are times when she doesn’t utter a single noise before her self-control sets in, but there are plenty of other times when it takes her a number of barks to remember her training and seek out her reward. Because of the latter, more frequent scenario, Chase recently told me he thought this approach was rewarding her for barking and was therefore reinforcing the opposite behavior I wanted.
The same could be said for my approach with Sunny’s affinity for dashing out the front door. I’d love to say she comes back the moment I call her, but that’s rare. More often than not, she does some zoomies around the front yards of a few neighbors, picks one to pee on and then heeds my call, at which time, despite the belated obedience, she is rewarded.
Chase’s viewpoint is totally understandable and maybe he is right, but the way I see it is that Sunny probably isn’t going to grasp the nuances of how many barks are acceptable before choosing to stop or how much time or distance she can spend away from our front door before coming back.. yet, anyway. She needs it kept simple. If she stops barking at any point, yay! If she comes back to me, it’s a win! Her delayed obedience isn’t a cause for shame, which is an ineffectual tool that creates separation, but a reminder that she needs ongoing training which can’t help but draw us closer and reinforce what is good. But of course, she doesn’t need to know any of that… just that it is a joyful thing to return to me.
I think God takes a very similar approach with us. He doesn’t condemn us for all the things we are getting wrong or how delayed we are in the responses that bless us, others and Him, but He celebrates every single moment we choose to turn toward Him and what He has taught us. “Yay!,” He might say. “That’s a win!” There are certainly consequences that can happen as a result of our choices, just like the possibility of Sunny getting hit by a car when she’s racing around, but there is no longer any shame attached. Any poor choices simply point to an area where we lack understanding and need a bit more training, but we don’t even need to grasp that. All we need to know is that, no matter where we have been or for how long or why, there joy every time we return to Him.
So now there is no condemnation for those who belong to Christ Jesus. Romans 8:1

Paul Chastain from Missouri here. I loved your dog story. I think that God gives us many chances to get it right, and doesn’t condemn us for getting it wrong. Further on in Romans, however, Paul says ‘should sin more abound so that grace may much more abound? God forbid!’ There are no ‘get out of jail free cards with God. When we get it wrong (sin), He expects us to come to Him in an attitude of repentance and confess our sin to Him. He expects to live holy lives before Him. He is gracious and will forgive us, but after awhile, if we are still repeating the same sin, He WILL chastise us. It is for our own good, but He will still discipline us for it. Grace is free, but not greasy. We are still held to a standard of obedience in our behavior as related in God’s love letter to us. Keep writing and thinking, dear sister! ________________________________
By: phc1 on August 21, 2023
at 3:29 pm
Hi Paul. Thank you so much for reading this post and for taking the time to comment! I really appreciate your insight and look forward to a Romans Bible study I’m starting tomorrow which, I’m sure, will increase my understanding. I agree that God calls us to be holy and is constantly calling, leading and training us to that end. And I do believe he lets us feel the weight of our sin so that we see how much we need him. I probably didn’t articulate it very well, but what I was mostly trying to say is that there is no more shame or condemnation when we do turn away from sin and toward him. It’s like we are constant prodigals, losing sight of what is true and choosing our own way, but the moment we turn in his direction, he is there welcoming us home. After experiencing this over and over, we are transformed by his love and truth and grow into being able to make choices that are aligned with his heart.
By: Kara Luker on August 22, 2023
at 9:42 am